Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Christopher Schneider's avatar

On the UChicago policy - it's notable that the Law School and the Business School (where I work) have both adopted similar technology policies to the one you highlighted. AND the whole school has negotiated an enterprise license to Claude for all Faculty, Staff and students.

I think it's worth delineating the aspects of the policy. The major change I see is the shift to a default for a "tech-free" classroom for students. For the first year of the Law School and as the default for the business school, students are not allowed (with allowances for learning accommodations) to use technology (laptops, phones, tablets) in the classroom though individual professors can opt-out of this policy for class needs.

This policy recognizes that there's a context decision that is part of discerning wise use of AI tools, and a recognition that some contexts in education need to be designed in ways that recognize the shortcomings of digital tools for learning.

Will students creatively work around them? Of course, but that will take work - even removing Claude's watermark requires substantial editing which of course requires some thought. Requiring oral exams about papers submitted for Law students is exactly the kind of challenge a future lawyer needs to be ready for.

That being said - the instructor is still, as you observe, at the heart of helping students learn and it's that fundamental relationship and even apprenticeship in learning that AI is challenging all educators on.

Here's a good example of some experimentation from our context around creating compacts of AI-use within the classroom and navigating together when those agreements are broken: https://teaching.uchicago.edu/resources/benjamin-morgan-opt-inopt-out-approach-ai-use

In sum, I'll highlight this quote from UChicago President Paul Alivasatos to the University about AI: "The University has a duty of care to ensure that the education offered to you is responsive to these technological developments by teaching you how to think with machines, how to think without them, and how to think about them. "

Though I would add, it's not enough to learn how to think with, without, and about machines, but how to live with each other in the presence of these machines and I'll gladly follow DELTA doing this important work!

James Lee's avatar

Meaghan, thank you for this post and for all that you're doing to serve Catholic educators. I am in the "let's figure out how to use AI to serve human flourishing" boat. Pope Leo invited us to "build the New Jerusalem" while recognizing we could also choose to build the next Babel.

I agree with you that AI bans are silly. Students still need to learn to think without it, like they need to learn to add without a calculator. But at some point calculators are pretty handy, even scientific and graphing ones. To me, AI is the linguistic counterpoise. It shouldn't be used all the time for everything. But it can be awfully handy.

I'm a baby on substack, but if you'd like to take a look I do write about becoming "more human with AI." God bless.

7 more comments...

Ready for more?