Over the past two weeks, I’ve been on the road to four Indiana colleges, speaking at faculty orientations about our work here at Notre Dame with DELTA and hosting conversations on strategies for AI in the classroom. This has been a dream come true, because I unabashedly love back-to-school season, and this year I get to run it on repeat, celebrating first days with a bunch of other schools in addition to Notre Dame. (Seriously, I was one of those children who would start counting down the days on July 5. One of my favorite smells is new Trapper Keeper.) So I have been humming Billy Madison as I drive through cornfields around the state marking this holiday with thousands of colleagues.
Just about every teacher I know has this feeling of joy and anticipation about opening a new year. But this August, that joy comes with a powerful undercurrent of anxiety about AI’s growing presence in the classroom. Claude has obliterated our syllabi. Questions of AI policy are increasingly polarizing colleagues. Every administrative leader I have met with knows that they need a strategy around this and fast. But which direction should we go in?
This edition of The Human DELTA is for all of the teachers celebrating back to school right now, even with the robot invasion in full swing. Don’t lose hope! We have survived periods of uncertainty before! We’re built to evolve. Here are a few back to school hot takes from my odyssey up and down Highway 31…
Dignity of Learning
Right now, one of my primary goals is helping educators feel empowered to make decisions about how to use artificial intelligence that are informed by a commitment to human dignity. The big discussion up in the Institute for Ethics and the Common Good all summer has centered around the dignity of learning, and I’ve noticed that this discussion is hitting a nerve with many of the faculty we have been speaking to at orientations this month.
The Catholic world has ~140 years or so of thinking about the dignity of work, and has surfed the waves of successive periods of industrialization and automation by constantly refocusing our attention on what humans need from an increasingly automated economy.
Three ideas have formed the core of the movement for the dignity of work since the late 1800s:
Work is an essential part of a good human life, because work is nothing more or less than our ability to serve the common good.
Some forms of work are humanizing, and some forms are dehumanizing. A kindergarten teacher helping a child learn to read is participating in a deeply human task for both himself and his pupil. A factory owner putting a child to work making soccer balls – not so much.
Work has both objective and subjective value. The objective value of work is its outputs. How many shirts did you make in the factory this week? How much cancer was cured by your research? The subjective value of work is the way it transforms your character. Hopefully you don’t have to choose between the two values, but if you do, then you should choose to tend to your soul rather than to make more widgets. Or so the Church argues.
AI is also changing our cognitive work. And we at the Institute think that means it’s time to update the dignity discussion to focus specifically on the dignity of learning. You don’t have to squint to see there are three similar principles for cognitive automation.
Learning is an essential part of a good human life, because our minds were designed to grow, to contemplate truth, and to be exercised for deeper understanding.
Some forms of learning are humanizing, and some are dehumanizing. See previous point about learning to read. During the COVID-19 pandemic, we stumbled upon a vast number of experiments in learning and discovered that many of them were dehumanizing. Having a third grader sit in front of a screen taking asynchronous reading quizzes all day – that’s dehumanizing.
Learning has both objective value (the external value of your skill) and subjective value (the way it changes you as a learner).
I’ve seen that many college professors are looking for ways to articulate to nervous students and parents the importance of this third idea. AI is raising profound questions about the objective value of human work, especially as we watch capabilities of AIs increasingly eclipse what humans can objectively produce doing cognitive work. We are walking into this school year with the stomach churning worry that no college education, however good it is, is going to beat the robots on this dimension of the productivity game. (This has Bill Gates particularly worried this week!)
But no matter how disrupted the economy gets, there will always be an essential subjective value to education. It changes who you are. Education literally rewires the architecture of your mind. And here is my hot take: that alone is worth defending even as AI changes the terms of “knowledge production.” Indeed, I think all three of the principles of the dignity of learning are worth fighting for, and teachers are going to be on the ones on the front lines of this campaign.
OK but enough philosophy – what are we actually going to do this year? Here my takes get a little hotter. Hey, I’m a philosopher. Objections are my love language. Lets get into the debates.
Hot Take 1: Abstention policies probably won’t work in college classrooms
The hot button issue everyone is talking about during all of these back to school events is whether faculty who care about the dignity of learning should just ban AI across the board. The University of Chicago was in the news this week for implementing a hard ban on AI in all of their core social science courses. I have to admit, I read that story and immediately wondered whether U of C is also banning students from using common spreadsheet programs in their social science core classes. Are they going to ban statistics software like SPSS and Stata too? Because here’s the thing: increasingly all software has AI capabilities embedded within it. Heck there is AI in my plumbing system in South Bend now! AI is everywhere! A few years ago it was still conceptually possible for me to “ban AI” but still have my students write papers on word processors. But now Word, Google Docs, you name it — they are all integrating AI features. These classroom bans proceed on the assumption that the old non-AI software tools we grew up on are going to stay available. Or that we are going to start teaching college level classes without any software components. Or that we are all going to implement really hard firewalls on software we permit students to learn with. It just seems quixotic.
My Institute colleagues don’t agree with me on everything (which, by the way, I love — it makes for a great team culture and better work) but this might be one of my spiciest takes within our DELTA team: Blanket, unrelenting, abstention policies are not going to work. I didn’t always think this — up until two years ago, I was squarely “team abstention.” In my own “God and the Good Life” course, I would stand up on the first day of class and say, “If you use an LLM, you are cheating, and you will receive a zero on the assignment.” Besides the pragmatic issues, I also started to have grave moral worries about my abstention policy, and this was what finally put me over the edge into revoking it. The abstention policy began to feel like I was making my students do the hard work of imagining what it’s like to learn philosophy without using these AI tools that are now everywhere. But really, I get paid the big bucks to figure out how to teach philosophy knowing that these tools are around. As a professor, I have more of a responsibility to help students develop the critical thinking abilities they will need rather than forcing them to figure out a way to work around my desire to go back in time. It’s up to me to coach students on how to develop the key writing and thinking skills that are the point of this class, realizing that when they’re not in my class, AI is going to be a part of their life.
If a student just prompts Claude or Gemini outside of class and copies the output, their work is going to be thoroughly “mid.” It’s a B+ essay at best. As these models get more capable at mimicking basic prose, our job isn’t to play an exhausting game of Whack-A-Mole with inaccurate detectors (more on this below). We have to rethink what it means to teach our disciplines in a way an algorithm cannot optimize. We should guide students on how to use AI thoughtfully—for brainstorming or kicking writer’s block —while making sure the deep, formative intellectual struggle stays intact. It’s going to take work to redefine what teaching means in this new landscape. We better start figuring it out.
Hot Take 2: If you care about human dignity, you probably should be talking more about AI. AI itself is an excellent philosophical muse – lean into the discussions in your class!
One of the most important things I want students to realize is that they have an inner life that is worth taking care of and fostering. I’m excited to debate with my students: what kinds of inner life can happen in an extended mind and what kinds of inner life can you only cultivate when you’re unplugged?
For the past few years, I have started my “God and the Good Life” course with a thought experiment called the Guru app. Students in my class debate and tease out how philosophers throughout history may respond to this thought experiment:
Imagine that Sam Altman, CEO of OpenAI, has just announced a new AI product: the Guru app. Sam has collected perfect data for the last 10 years from every human being on earth, and has used it to build a model that predicts human satisfaction. You can ask the Guru app any question (Should I become a vegan? Should I quit my job? Should I dye my hair?), and it uses the data set about human satisfaction and every detail it has about you, to give you advice that guarantees satisfaction. Should we turn our decision-making over to this app?
I’m always surprised, in the best way, by the range of responses my students tease out as they think through this scenario, and it illustrates that technology can provoke philosophical inquiry. We don’t immediately assume that technology is the enemy, but it can help us wrestle with deeper human questions. Our students live in an age embedded with technology – it’s just part of their reality – and philosophy is done best when it’s in touch with the lived human experience.
Everyone I have been meeting with on the road is frantically putting the finishing touches on their syllabi. If you’re finding yourself stumped, wondering how to open space for debate about the role of AI in your particular learning community, don’t stress. You don’t need to reinvent the wheel. When faculty ask me what to assign to get students digging deep to think about the real stakes of technological change, I keep pointing them toward the two amazing texts that came out this year about what it means to live in a world with powerful AI. The integral text is of course, Pope Leo’s encyclical, Magnifica Humanitas [(you can read our Substack post on it).
The other text is Anthropic’s Claude Constitution. This summer we held a week-long graduate seminar just looking at the Claude Constitution and its philosophical questions (stay tuned for a Substack entry coming soon). It’s been a fun season to teach these texts, and really, it’s an opportunity to get curious and excited. I think nearly any college professor could use these texts to start a debate with their students this fall, and in the process help them wrestle with some profound questions about what it means to be a human with dignity.
Hot Take 3: There are no silver bullets and be wary of the promises of EdTech
I get pitched on a new AI EdTech product practically every single day. There is an entire industry of consultants and companies out there trying to sell college professors the “silver bullet” for what education should look like in the age of AI. While these tools are pushed aggressively at educators right now, I am cautious against the panicked rush to hop on the bandwagon. Instead of outsourcing our teaching to an unproven techno-solution, what if we were to turn to the hard-earned practical wisdom we’ve developed in our fields? Can we trust that we know how to defend the dignity of learning without needing an algorithm to do it for us?
On a related note, if somebody is trying to sell you software that claims it can reliably detect the outputs of generative AI, you’d be better off investing in oceanfront property in Arizona. Reliably AI detectors do not exist. And you are also not necessarily a reliable AI detector. I get the temptation: as students increasingly use AI, administrators and panicked faculty want an easy technological fix to police academic integrity. But the plain reality is that these detectors are just not there technologically, and leaning on them leads to false accusations and a breakdown of trust. If you’re holding out hope for watermarking to save the day, don’t hold your breath. Many models don’t even use them, and any student can easily strip a watermark by generating text and modifying it heavily with their own words.
Fellow professors, we got this! We’ve faced big transitions before, and when we’re weathered them successfully, it’s been because we’ve kept the main thing the main thing —- safeguarding the dignity and agency of the humans we teach and equipping them with the disciplinary skills they need to navigate this transition.
Those of us on the DELTA Force are on this ride with you, and we’ll be adding oodles of new resources for educators to our brand spankin’ new DELTA website in the coming weeks. We also want to hear from you: What are the biggest questions circling around AI in your world? What’s working in your classes? Drop us a comment below!



On the UChicago policy - it's notable that the Law School and the Business School (where I work) have both adopted similar technology policies to the one you highlighted. AND the whole school has negotiated an enterprise license to Claude for all Faculty, Staff and students.
I think it's worth delineating the aspects of the policy. The major change I see is the shift to a default for a "tech-free" classroom for students. For the first year of the Law School and as the default for the business school, students are not allowed (with allowances for learning accommodations) to use technology (laptops, phones, tablets) in the classroom though individual professors can opt-out of this policy for class needs.
This policy recognizes that there's a context decision that is part of discerning wise use of AI tools, and a recognition that some contexts in education need to be designed in ways that recognize the shortcomings of digital tools for learning.
Will students creatively work around them? Of course, but that will take work - even removing Claude's watermark requires substantial editing which of course requires some thought. Requiring oral exams about papers submitted for Law students is exactly the kind of challenge a future lawyer needs to be ready for.
That being said - the instructor is still, as you observe, at the heart of helping students learn and it's that fundamental relationship and even apprenticeship in learning that AI is challenging all educators on.
Here's a good example of some experimentation from our context around creating compacts of AI-use within the classroom and navigating together when those agreements are broken: https://teaching.uchicago.edu/resources/benjamin-morgan-opt-inopt-out-approach-ai-use
In sum, I'll highlight this quote from UChicago President Paul Alivasatos to the University about AI: "The University has a duty of care to ensure that the education offered to you is responsive to these technological developments by teaching you how to think with machines, how to think without them, and how to think about them. "
Though I would add, it's not enough to learn how to think with, without, and about machines, but how to live with each other in the presence of these machines and I'll gladly follow DELTA doing this important work!
Meaghan, thank you for this post and for all that you're doing to serve Catholic educators. I am in the "let's figure out how to use AI to serve human flourishing" boat. Pope Leo invited us to "build the New Jerusalem" while recognizing we could also choose to build the next Babel.
I agree with you that AI bans are silly. Students still need to learn to think without it, like they need to learn to add without a calculator. But at some point calculators are pretty handy, even scientific and graphing ones. To me, AI is the linguistic counterpoise. It shouldn't be used all the time for everything. But it can be awfully handy.
I'm a baby on substack, but if you'd like to take a look I do write about becoming "more human with AI." God bless.